An Open Letter On Graphic Imagery In Pro-life Activism,

Well I’ve never been more nervous to click publish in my life.  This piece is an “in house memo” if you will to others who share my belief that abortion is the denial of a child’s inherent right to life.  If you are one of my readers who is pro-choice, understand that I love and respect you and believe that you act from good intentions.  I also think you are wrong.  I would expect you could say the same to me.  I will not debate abortion in a comments section because it is a deeply emotional and personal matter that cannot be spoken about well in that context.  If you would like to speak to me about it however let me know and we can find a better way to discuss our differences.

 

 

Dear Fellow Pro-lifer,

I have wanted to write you this letter for some time but I have been afraid.  I have been afraid to be chastised by you, I have been afraid of seeming to condemn you.  I have also been ashamed, because to do so I must reveal things I do not like about myself and will always regret. I have said before that I believe there is room in the pro-life movement for all moral tactics in defending life.  If one approach saves a life and something else saves another then we are right to have both.  I know some images of aborted children have swayed hearts and minds.  In light of the recent videos from CMP it is quite clear that shocking visuals can open a national debate.  As a student of history I believe atrocities must be recorded.  As a lover of truth I acknowledge you share the reality of what happens in an abortion clinic over and over every day.  However, in a nutshell, I wish to make you aware that your images sometimes have a different effect on those who see them than you intend.

The first time I saw a picture of abortion was as a freshman in college attending the March for Life.  As we walked down the streets of DC, I was overwhelmed with a sense of hope. I had never realized how many other young people were willing to stand up for the unborn.  My mood was elated.  Then I walked past a poster of a dismembered fetus in a dish.  Suddenly I was filled with disgust.  And here comes my first confession, I was not filled with horror at abortion.  I was viscerally disgusted by the baby.  In fact my thought was “Oh God, what is that thing.”  I looked away, and made sure to always avoid those images in future.  Not because it disturbed me that people perpetrated such evil; that had always been the case.  No.  I looked away because I was revolted by that disgusting Thing lying there in a mess of blood in a dish.  It was the first time in my entire life that fetus had not seemed synonymous with baby.  It was alien, other, and utterly repulsive.  It looked like that “mass of tissue” pro-choicers insisted on talking about.

Well, for a long time that was the end of it. I was deeply ashamed of my feelings, but I knew I was pro-life.  I heard that some people were shocked into facing hard truths by those pictures.  Why share with anyone that I, who loved the unborn, felt not pity but an involuntary abhorrence when looking at them?  Years went by.  I had four children of my own.  I heard of friends’ miscarriages and mourned their children with them knowing those were human persons gone forever.  Then at a 19 week ultrasound for our fifth child they told me he was terribly small and not getting enough blood flow.  At 21 weeks we returned to make a plan to save him. He was already dead.

I wept for my lost child.  But I also felt an overwhelming fear.   I screamed, “I can’t, I can’t.” Most of what I meant was: I can’t endure the pain of this loss.  But I also meant: I can’t bear to face one of those strange alien things from the posters.   I feared seeing my baby.  I feared that I would see him and he would repel me like all those images of aborted fetuses.  What if I, his mother, rejected him because he seemed hideous?

Luckily I talked to my husband over the internet.  He was stationed in Guam at the time and I told him my shameful secret: I did not want to look at our son.  He told me about his brother who had died at a similar age and who he had seen as a young teen.  He gently explained that I did not have to look but that he thought I should, that I would regret it if I did not, and that I would not have the reaction I expected.

Still I went into the hospital worried.  When the baby was delivered there were complications and I needed immediate surgery.  Before I was wheeled from the room they asked if I wanted to see Charlie.  I said not yet, later.  So it was that I was not the first person to hold my son.  My wonderful aunts held him and blessed his body and waited with him until I awoke from surgery.  Then I prepared myself and they brought him to me.

He was beautiful, a beautiful little boy in every way.  I held him.  I marveled at his hand resting softly in mine.  I kissed his cool forehead.  I hugged him and whispered to him.  Still it will always be one of my greatest, most painful regrets that I was too scared of my son to do him the honor of holding him first.  When we lost our sixth child nine months later at 17 weeks gestation, I desperately desired to hold him immediately.  I knew what a wondrous little child he would be.  He was snuggled up just sleeping with the most breathtakingly beautiful little toes and a faint smile on his lips.  I hope Charlie understands that when I held Samuel I tried to make up for the way I had failed his older brother.

You see, your images, meant to inspire a sense of the enormity of taking a human life and the brutality of those who do so, had made me afraid of my own son, made me treat him as a terrifying foreign creature and not a baby boy.  Now it is not you who dehumanized the child in those images and videos.  I know that.  He was killed by others who destroyed his dignity as a person.  But I want you to know that where you may see one thing, others may see something else.  If I, a deeply pro-life woman, could be made to feel this way then surely some others who have hardened their hearts already against the unborn feel similarly.  They are repulsed, they are angry.  It is a natural instinct to turn away from horror, to protect ourselves from it even at the expense of intellectual honesty.  They see a shattered, torn mess and not a human child.  They see that child as less related to the human family, not more.

So why am I writing this?  I guess I just want you to know.  Perhaps this will change the times and ways in which you use these violent images.  Perhaps it will help you to understand the attitudes and reactions of those you are trying to sway, which can seem to us callous, obstinate or blind. Perhaps it will prompt you to balance imagery that documents the atrocities perpetrated on the innocent with imagery that emphasizes the inherent beauty of those innocents.  For example, you may be surprised to know that I cherish and share pictures of my two sons.  Photos like these I think reveal the dignity of the fetus and the relationship of mother and child.  One in four pregnancies ends in loss and the indescribable pain and confusion of mourning a child’s death in a world where many do not acknowledge their short life.  Many other women are considering abortion in a world that portrays unwanted children as frightening, invading, inhuman creatures.  If anyone else has felt the revulsion and fear I felt, I want to assure you, most certainly, that a child meant to be in the womb, still being knit together by God, is a truly beautiful, human, fragile yet perfect person.

Sincerely In Christ,

Caitlin Marchand
 

Advertisements

7 Comments

Filed under Religious Ramblings, Uncategorized

7 responses to “An Open Letter On Graphic Imagery In Pro-life Activism,

  1. You are courageous and beautiful, like your little lost boys. It was very brave to write this vulnerable and heart wrenchingly honest letter. I agree that the beauty of the growing child in the womb should be emphasized, because then the truth speaks so gently yet powerfully, in a way that simply states a reality, and doesn’t make people avert their eyes and run away.
    Love to you as ever and you carry on despite your grief. Thanks for being a voice of love for every little person. How much they all matter!
    Anna

    • Thank you for your words of support, I was very frightened to post this. You remain in our prayers!

      • I’m really with you on this. I’ve had much more positive influence by showing coworkers or friends doctors drawings of baby week by week in pregnancy and sharing my joy and wonder at this little life, than by trying to argue about it in a negative way.
        Thank you for the prayers which have cushioned my heart on our recent 1 year anniversary and kept me very peaceful.

  2. The WhimsicalWitch

    I’m glad you wrote about this. I’ve felt the same way ever since I was required to attend a March for Life and saw graphic images of aborted fetuses. I feel that repercussions of some pro-life tactics aren’t considered because the pro-life movement is quick to justify any methods that get their point across. Often I think they do themselves a disservice in regards to graphic imgagery. But as you pointed out, the abortion debate is very emotionally charged and it’s difficult to engage either side without arousing anger or hurt or judgement.

    • Yes. I wonder for every mind changed by graphic imagery how many are closed off because of it. I don’t know. I certainly feel that the sense of assault where you were not warned or prepared for an image is likely to have adverse responses quite often. But it’s difficult to know what to think over all. Thank you for saying you felt the same way. I was worried I was the only person with this particular reaction and that pro-lifers would all just be appalled at my insensitivity.

  3. This is one of the most beautiful, heart-wrenching posts I’ve read to date. I’m in tears now, and I can’t tell you how much I admire your courage in writing this.

    In short, I agree 100%. Also, as someone who used to be pro-choice and is now a passionate pro-lifer, I’ve always disagreed with the use of graphic images. (For a variety of reasons, and it would take far too long for me to type out my response. PM me if you want me to elaborate, and I’d be happy to do so).

    You, Mike and your children are always in our prayers.

  4. Pingback: Simmer Starters - January 22, 2016 - The Simmering Mind

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s